How to Play Sergeant Major (3-5-8)
Sergeant Major, often called 3-5-8 or 8-5-3, is a three-player trick-taking game in which the dealer aims for eight tricks, the player on the dealer’s left for five, and the remaining player for three. Every hand contains sixteen tricks. Players who exceed their target are “up” and players below it are “down”; later deals include special card exchanges between those players. The first person to take at least twelve tricks in a single deal wins.
Sergeant Major (3-5-8) quick rules
In brief: Sergeant Major, often called 3-5-8 or 8-5-3, is a three-player trick-taking game in which the dealer aims for eight tricks, the player on the dealer’s left for five, and the remaining player for three. Every hand contains sixteen tricks. Players who exceed their target are “up” and players below it are “down”; later deals include special card exchanges between those players. The first person to take at least twelve tricks in a single deal wins.
- Use a standard 52-card deck without jokers with exactly three players, each playing individually.
- Deal 16 cards face down to each person and place the last four into a face-down kitty.
- The dealer names one suit as trump, discards any four cards, and takes the four kitty cards to restore a 16-card hand.
- The dealer’s trick target is 8; the player to the dealer’s left targets 5; the player to the dealer’s right targets 3.
- The player left of the dealer leads. Follow the led suit if possible; if void, you can play any card.
- Highest trump wins a trick; without trump, highest card of the led suit wins. Trick winner leads the next.
- After 16 tricks, compare results with each person’s target: over-target players are up, under-target players are down.
- On future deals, people who were up pass one unwanted card per overtrick to those who were down, receiving the highest card of each passed card’s suit in return.
- Only after exchanges does the new dealer name trump, discard four and pick up kitty cards.
- Continue until any player wins at least 12 of the 16 tricks in a single hand.
Rules version: Pagat’s original three-player Sergeant Major: 16-card hands, 8–5–3 quotas and 12-trick victory.
Three players and the 52-card deal
Sergeant Major is played by three individuals with a standard 52-card pack, no jokers. The game ranks cards ace high, then king, queen, jack, 10 down to two. Play and dealing are clockwise. There are no fixed partnerships.
Choose the first dealer at random. Deal one card at a time until every player has sixteen cards. Set the remaining four cards face down as the kitty (also called the widow). The number check is 3 × 16 + 4 = 52.
Before looking at kitty, the dealer chooses a trump suit from hearts, diamonds, clubs and spades, then puts aside any four cards from the original hand face down. Dealer picks up the four unknown kitty cards afterward, returning to sixteen cards. No-trump play is not allowed in the core rules.
There are exactly sixteen tricks in a normal hand: each player contributes one card to each. The first trick is led by the person left of the dealer.
Who needs eight, five and three tricks?
The targets depend entirely on seating relative to the current dealer. The dealer is the major, expected to win eight tricks. The person on the dealer’s left tries to win five, and the person on the right tries for three. Together the targets account for all sixteen tricks, so the game balances every overtrick with another player’s shortfall.
| Seat relative to dealer | Trick target |
|---|---|
| Dealer | 8 |
| Left of dealer (first leader) | 5 |
| Right of dealer | 3 |
These roles rotate with the deal. If Alex deals now and aims for eight, Blair may take the deal next and become the player needing eight. The target does not remain associated with one person throughout the match.
The aim is not to hit the target exactly as in Oh Hell. Taking more than your target is desirable, since those extra tricks create a favorable position for card exchange next time.
Choosing trump and using the kitty
On the first deal, the dealer assesses the original sixteen-card hand, announces a suit as trump, discards four cards before seeing the kitty, and then draws the kitty’s four cards unseen until that choice is complete. This prevents a dealer from choosing the exact four discards with complete knowledge of the 52-card distribution.
For example, if Alex has a long strong spade suit, Alex might choose spades as trump and discard four weak cards from other suits. The kitty may then add useful spades, or it may contain cards that do not particularly help. The uncertainty is part of the game.
When the dealer changes on the next round, the new dealer gains the same right to choose trump. But starting with the second deal, the compulsory exchanges based on the previous hand take place before trump is named and before the four cards are discarded.
Some related 3-5-8 games allow the dealer to look at kitty first and then discard. That is a documented variation, not the exact procedure used here.
Playing sixteen tricks
The player left of the dealer leads the first trick and may choose any card. Moving clockwise, each other player must follow suit if able. If unable to follow, they can play any card, whether trump or a card in another suit. The trick belongs to the highest trump played or, if none appears, to the highest card of the led suit.
- Leader places any card face up.
- Second and third players follow the led suit if they possess it, or play any card if void.
- Determine whether a trump was played; the highest trump beats every non-trump.
- Collect the three-card trick for its winner.
- Winner leads the next trick.
- Continue for sixteen tricks and count each person’s total.
Example: hearts are trump, Alex leads Q♠, Blair follows A♠ and Casey, void in spades, plays 2♥. Casey wins the trick with the two of trump, even though Blair played an ace. If Casey had discarded a club instead, Blair’s A♠ would win.
There is no bidding round after trump is chosen. The targets are set by seating, not by each player’s estimates.
Up, down and exact trick differences
After all sixteen tricks, subtract each player’s target from the number actually won. A positive difference is called up; a negative difference is down. Someone who hits the target exactly is even. The differences must sum to zero because the target total is sixteen and all sixteen tricks were captured.
In that deal, the dealer earned one extra trick and the player left of dealer missed one. Those two players will perform a one-card exchange in the next deal, using the previous outcome to determine who gives an unwanted card and who returns a better one.
Traditional rules often describe one unit of settlement per trick above or below target. For a family game, record these differences on a sheet without money; the running numbers are useful for tracking performance, but the overall win condition is twelve tricks in one hand, not reaching a cumulative numeric total.
How the next hand’s compulsory trades work
From the second deal onward, cards are first dealt exactly as before, sixteen each plus a four-card kitty. Then each person who was up on the previous hand passes one unwanted card for each overtrick to someone who was down. The receiving player returns the highest card of that same suit from their hand for each card received.
For example, Alex was up two and Blair down two. In the next deal, Alex passes 4♠ and 6♦ face down to Blair. Blair must return Blair’s highest spade and highest diamond. Blair may be forced to give up A♠ and K♦ if those are the best ranks of the corresponding suits in Blair’s hand.
If the receiver holds no card of a given suit other than the one passed, they may have to give that same card back. The game does not allow them to substitute a high card of a different suit.
These trades give the successful players better cards in the following deal, while players who missed their targets must surrender useful cards. However, the dealer’s quota and trump-selection privilege rotate, so the overall situation can still change from round to round.
When more than one player is up
If one player was up and the other two were down, that player distributes cards to each down player equal to their respective trick shortfalls, and each returns highest cards in the suits received. All those initial card passes are made simultaneously.
If two players were up and only one down, the up player with the higher target in the hand about to begin trades first. The down player returns matching-suit highest cards to that player before the other up player conducts a separate exchange.
Once all required exchanges are complete, the new dealer names trump, discards four, and picks up the four kitty cards. If the dealer was down and had to give away the highest card of a suit, but a stronger card of that suit comes from kitty, the dealer must privately show it to the player who received a weaker card in the previous exchange, under the main source’s verification convention.
Because this step can be complicated for beginners, keep a small note of the preceding deal’s up/down values and confirm the seat targets for the upcoming deal before exchanging anything.
How to win Sergeant Major
One player wins the whole game immediately by capturing twelve or more tricks in a single sixteen-trick hand. This threshold is independent of the seat’s usual target of eight, five or three and independent of earlier cumulative overtricks.
For example, Casey is in the three-trick seat but manages to capture twelve tricks by using many high trump cards. Casey wins immediately, even though the scheduled target was only three. It is not necessary to wait for the new dealer or perform the next card exchange.
It may take many hands to reach twelve captured tricks because players gain and lose strong cards through the exchange system. Some households prefer a time limit or a cumulative target to prevent very long sessions, but those are alternative match endings.
Sergeant Major strategy
Choose trump to support your eight-trick quota. The dealer has the largest target, but also gets to name trump and take the kitty. A long suit with high cards can be preferable to a short suit with one ace.
Try to finish up, not merely even. Surpassing your quota creates the right to exchange weak cards for another player’s strongest card of the matching suit next deal. That can make future hands considerably stronger.
Think about which suits to pass. When you were up, choosing a low card from a suit in which the down player may have strong holdings can produce a powerful return. But the other person’s exact cards are unknown.
Keep an eye on the twelve-trick threshold. An opponent at ten tricks with several left to play may be closer to winning the whole game than the quota sheet suggests.
Sergeant Major and related 3-5-8 games
Picking up kitty first
Some groups allow the dealer to inspect the four kitty cards before selecting the four discards, changing the trump and hand-selection advantage.
9-5-2
A Canadian variation assigns quotas of nine, five and two tricks. This is a related game but uses different targets and often different card exchanges.
51-card 8-6-3
A published variation removes 2♣, deals 17 cards each and changes quotas to eight, six and three. It may finish when someone reaches a running +10 instead of twelve tricks in a single deal.
Win all sixteen tricks
Another house ending requires one player to capture all sixteen. That can greatly extend the match; the main guide uses twelve.
Sergeant Major frequently asked questions
How many players?
Exactly three in the standard game.
How many cards are dealt?
Sixteen per player, with four face down in the kitty.
What are the targets?
Dealer eight, player left of dealer five, player right of dealer three.
Who chooses trump?
The dealer, before discarding four and picking up the kitty.
Do you have to follow suit?
Yes if able, otherwise you may play any card.
What does up mean?
Winning more tricks than your seat’s target. Down means winning fewer.
Do players swap cards?
Yes, from the second deal onward, based on up/down results from the preceding deal.
Does the game end at +10 points?
Not in the selected main version. It ends when one player captures at least twelve tricks in a single hand.
Related card games
Rules references and variants
Several regional games use the name 3-5-8. This guide uses a specific version and labels different quota and win conditions separately.
- Pagat — Sergeant Major: Original 52-card 3-5-8 version, exchanges, trump and twelve-trick finish.
- VIPGames — How to Play Sergeant Major: Secondary overview of the three-player 3-5-8 quotas and card exchanges.